Cigar Reviews - Puroexpress Blog

Welcome to the Puroexpress Cigar Rating System

At Puroexpress, we are passionate about providing cigar enthusiasts with the finest smoking experiences. Our cigar rating system is designed to offer clear, reliable assessments of the cigars we feature, helping you make informed choices. We pride ourselves on our meticulous rating process, which reflects our commitment to quality and excellence in every puff.

How We Rate Our Cigars

Our rating system is based on a thorough evaluation process that considers several critical aspects of each cigar. Here’s how we break down our ratings and what we look for:

1. Construction and Appearance

Construction: We inspect the cigar for its overall build quality, including the firmness, the evenness of the roll, and the quality of the cap. A well-constructed cigar should feel firm yet resilient when gently squeezed. Appearance: The visual appeal of the cigar matters. We look at the color, texture, and sheen of the wrapper. A good cigar has an even, attractive wrapper with minimal blemishes.

2. Pre-Light Experience

Aroma: Before lighting, we take note of the cigar’s aroma. This can provide early indications of the flavor profile to come. Cold Draw: We evaluate the draw of the unlit cigar, assessing the airflow and initial flavors.

3. Flavor Profile

Our tasting process involves analyzing the flavors at different stages of the cigar. We look for complexity, balance, and progression of flavors: Initial Flavors: The first few puffs set the stage. We identify primary notes, such as spice, sweetness, or earthiness. Development: As the cigar burns, the flavors should evolve. We look for transitions and how new notes emerge and blend with the initial flavors. Finish: A great cigar leaves a lasting impression. We assess the aftertaste and how the flavors linger.

4. Burn and Draw

Burn: A well-made cigar burns evenly and consistently. We look for a steady burn line and how well the cigar holds its ash. Draw: The draw should be smooth and effortless, providing ample smoke without being too tight or too loose.

5. Overall Experience

We combine our observations to provide an overall score. This includes considering the cigar’s balance, complexity, and the enjoyment it provides.

Our Rating Scale

96-100: Masterpiece

These cigars represent the pinnacle of cigar craftsmanship, offering an extraordinary smoking experience with unparalleled complexity and balance.

91-95: Exceptional

Outstanding cigars with superior quality and remarkable flavor profiles. These are top-tier cigars offering a premium smoking experience.

86-90: Excellent

High-quality cigars that deliver a consistently satisfying smoking experience. They feature solid construction, enjoyable flavors, and reliable performance.

80-85: Very Good

Good quality cigars with noticeable strengths but some minor imperfections. They offer enjoyable smoking experiences with good flavor and decent construction.

70-79: Good to Average

Decent cigars suitable for everyday smoking but with noticeable flaws. These cigars have acceptable construction and flavor but may have issues that affect the overall experience.

Below 70: Not Recommended

Cigars with significant flaws that detract from the smoking experience. These cigars may suffer from poor construction, lackluster flavors, or major inconsistencies and are generally not recommended for purchase.

N/A: Not Rated

Cigars that have not been rated. These cigars have not undergone the rating process or are not available for review.

Conclusion

Our goal at Puroexpress is to ensure that every cigar we recommend meets the highest standards of quality and satisfaction. Whether you’re a seasoned aficionado or new to the world of cigars, our rating system is here to guide you towards the best smoking experiences. Thank you for trusting us with your cigar journey. Happy smoking!